AttendMe Owl Logo
AttendMe
Evidence Evolution
Orthopedic SurgeryOrthopedic Surgery

How This Evidence Evolved

Rotator Cuff Repair Indications

From early repair to shared decision-making and sham-surgery evidence

28.3

Timeline

Signal

Early observations and pilot data that first suggested a new direction

Proof

Landmark RCTs and pivotal trials that established the evidence base

Trials of subacromial decompression and rotator cuff repair studied different populations. CSAW enrolled patients with intact rotator cuff tendons. Decompression offered no extra benefit over arthroscopy alone; both surgical groups had small, clinically unimportant benefits over no treatment at 6 months. FIMPACT found no benefit of decompression over diagnostic arthroscopy at 24 months. In contrast, Moosmayer’s trial randomized 103 patients with small-to-medium tears to repair or physiotherapy and reported better results with repair, including a 13.0-point Constant score difference. Lambers Heerspink’s 2015 trial found no significant Constant-Murley score difference at 12 months (81.9 versus 73.7; P=0.08), but pain and disability scores favored surgery (P=0.04 and P=0.02). These findings distinguish decompression for subacromial pain from tendon repair for rotator cuff tears.
Extension

Follow-up studies, subgroup analyses, and real-world validation

A synthesis of 31 Cochrane reviews favored strengthening exercises, with or without manual therapy and other resources, for medium- and long-term shoulder pain. The 2019 Cochrane repair review found uncertain clinically meaningful benefit from surgery versus exercise-based care at one year. Its evidence chiefly concerned small degenerative supraspinatus tears and may not apply to traumatic or large tears or young patients. Moosmayer provides a different long-term comparison: 103 patients with tears ≤3 cm were randomized to primary repair or physiotherapy with optional secondary repair. At 10 years, primary repair was better by 9.6 Constant points (P=.002), 15.7 ASES points (P<.001), and 1.8 cm on a 10-cm pain scale (P<.001). Fourteen crossed from physiotherapy to surgery. Differences increased over time.
Now

Current standard of care and ongoing research directions

Treatment should distinguish acute traumatic tears from chronic degeneration and isolated subacromial pain. Decisions should reflect function, tear features and patient preferences. This does not imply that repair and decompression have the same indications. Questions include whether PRP, stem cells or patches improve repair, whether prehabilitation helps and how prognosis can guide selection.

Landmark Trials in This Story

Kuhn 20132013

Effectiveness of physical therapy in treating atraumatic full-thickness rotator cuff tears: a multicenter prospective cohort study.

Physical therapy effective in approximately 75% at 2 years

Journal of shoulder and elbow surgeryMulticenter prospective cohort studyN=452
CSAW2018Landmark

Arthroscopic subacromial decompression for subacromial shoulder pain (CSAW): a multicentre, pragmatic, parallel group, placebo-controlled, three-group, randomised surgical trial

Oxford Shoulder Score at 6 months

LancetRCT (sham-controlled)N=313
Moosmayer 20102010

Comparison between surgery and physiotherapy in the treatment of small and medium-sized tears of the rotator cuff: A randomised controlled study of 103 patients with one-year follow-up.

Constant score at 12 months: repair versus physiotherapy (between-group difference 13.0 points).

The Journal of bone and joint surgery. British volumeRandomized controlled trialN=103
FIMPACT2018Landmark

Subacromial decompression versus diagnostic arthroscopy for shoulder impingement: randomised, placebo surgery controlled clinical trial

Visual analogue scale for pain at 2 years

BMJRCT (sham-controlled)N=210
Lambers Heerspink 20152015

Comparing surgical repair with conservative treatment for degenerative rotator cuff tears: a randomized controlled trial.

Constant-Murley score at 12 months: surgery 81.9 versus conservative treatment 73.7 (P=0.08).

Journal of shoulder and elbow surgeryRandomized controlled trialN=56
Cochrane review synthesis2019

What do Cochrane Systematic Reviews say about conservative and surgical therapeutic interventions for treating rotator cuff disease? Synthesis of evidence.

Treatment effectiveness over medium and long terms: strengthening exercises, with or without manual therapy and other resources, versus surgical procedures.

Sao Paulo medical journal = Revista paulista de medicinaReview of systematic reviews
Moosmayer 10-year2019

At a 10-Year Follow-up, Tendon Repair Is Superior to Physiotherapy in the Treatment of Small and Medium-Sized Rotator Cuff Tears

Constant Score at 10 years

J Bone Joint Surg AmRCT long-term follow-upN=103
Cochrane repair review 20192019

Surgery for rotator cuff tears.

Pain at 1 year: non-operative treatment 1.6/10; surgery 0.87 points better (95% CI 0.43–1.30 better)

The Cochrane database of systematic reviewsSystematic review of 9 randomized trialsN=1,007

Explore the evidence yourself

Ask AttendMe about any trial, guideline, or clinical question. Evidence-ranked answers from 3.7M+ peer-reviewed articles.

Related Evidence

Frequently Asked Questions

Should all rotator cuff tears be surgically repaired?+
No. Moosmayer’s trial compared primary repair with physiotherapy and optional secondary surgery for small-to-medium tears. At 10 years, primary repair had better Constant scores by 9.6 points (P=0.002); 14 patients crossed from physiotherapy to surgery.
What did the CSAW trial show about subacromial decompression?+
CSAW found no significant benefit of decompression over arthroscopy-only placebo for subacromial shoulder pain at six months. FIMPACT found no benefit over diagnostic arthroscopy at 24 months. CSAW suggested that the small, clinically unimportant advantage of both surgical groups over no treatment might reflect placebo or postoperative physiotherapy; it did not establish a predominantly placebo mechanism.

Medical Disclaimer: This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Clinical decisions should always be based on individual patient assessment, local guidelines, and professional judgement.

All data sourced from published, peer-reviewed articles and clinical practice guidelines.

Claims checked against cited sources: 10 November 2026